Blog field notes are now in print A long-form section has joined the reading room. Eleven essays are up, more on the way, and a comments thread if you would like to leave a thought.

← Cynicism

Page of Swords · Cynicism

Page of Swords Tarot Card and Diogenes: No Cuphood

Page of Swords

The archetype

The Page of Swords shows a young man gripping a sword, alert, as though ready to talk back at any moment. A Cynic looking at this thinks of a clash between Diogenes and Plato.

How does Cynicism read the Page of Swords?

According to Diogenes Laërtius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers VI.53, Plato was lecturing on his theory of Ideas and using words like “tablehood” and “cuphood.” Diogenes said: Plato, I can see a table and a cup, but your tablehood and cuphood I can’t see anywhere. Plato replied: that’s easily explained. You have eyes to see the table and the cup, but not the understanding to see tablehood and cuphood.

Diogenes’s line is sharp, aimed at anything that sounds profound but can’t be pinned down. Plato’s comeback is just as pointed. In this exchange both men have a point. The Page of Swords is quick-tongued and bold with questions, and reading this card, a Cynic admires his nerve in puncturing hot air, and reminds him: before you mock what others say they see, ask whether you’ve understood it yet.

Reading the Page of Swords upright

Upright, you dare to press on things that sound mystical and insist that people explain themselves.

Reading the Page of Swords reversed

Reversed, you may just be arguing for the sake of it, dismissing whatever you don’t understand as empty talk.

In love and connection

Speaking your mind in a relationship is good. Before you do, ask whether you’re after clarity or just want to win.

In work and direction

If a meeting throws a concept at you that you don’t follow, ask for an example, without embarrassment.

A question to sit with

Among the views you’ve argued against recently, is there one you hadn’t really understood?

A practice for this week

① Pick a view you’ve always dismissed. ② Read the best-argued article you can find in its favor. ③ Write down its strongest point.

A note on using this reading

This content is for self-reflection and entertainment only and does not constitute medical, legal, or financial advice.

Want a live reading for your own question? Draw with The Plain Speaker

Draw with Dian →

This page is generated from a 78×10 template matrix and editorially reviewed. It is not ten human authors writing separately. About · editorial standards