Blog field notes are now in print A long-form section has joined the reading room. Eleven essays are up, more on the way, and a comments thread if you would like to leave a thought.

← Phenomenology

Knight of Swords · Phenomenology

Knight of Swords Tarot Card and Edith Stein: Empathy

Knight of Swords

The archetype

The Knight of Swords looks only ahead. The birds and butterflies around him and the wind-bent trees flash past at the edge of his vision. A phenomenologist wonders: the person he’s charging toward, does he actually see them?

How does Phenomenology read the Knight of Swords?

Edith Stein was Edmund Husserl’s student and assistant, and her doctoral dissertation, On the Problem of Empathy (1917), asks how we experience other people’s experiences. Her example: a friend tells me he has lost his brother, and I become aware of his pain. The pain is his. I don’t live through it firsthand as my own, and yet I really do experience it, with its own weight.

Stein calls this kind of experience empathy and sees it as the ground of our life with others. What the Knight of Swords does best is argue and judge, charging in to make the case clear. Phenomenology would remind him: before you make your case, pause and see what the other person is going through right now.

Reading the Knight of Swords upright

Upright, you speak directly and you notice how the other person feels, so your words land precisely without wounding.

Reading the Knight of Swords reversed

Reversed, you may be so focused on winning the point that you haven’t noticed the other person is already hurting.

In love and connection

When your partner tells you what’s wrong, hold off on advice. Try saying: it sounds like this has been really hard.

In work and direction

Before you criticize a coworker, think about what their week might have been like.

A question to sit with

The last time you rushed to make your point, what was the other person going through?

A practice for this week

① In one conversation this week, before giving your view, say back what you hear the other person feeling. ② Notice how their response changes. ③ Write down what you noticed.

A note on using this reading

This content is for self-reflection and entertainment only and does not constitute medical, legal, or financial advice.

Want a live reading for your own question? Draw with The Mirror of Experience

Draw with Mirae →

This page is generated from a 78×10 template matrix and editorially reviewed. It is not ten human authors writing separately. About · editorial standards