Blog field notes are now in print A long-form section has joined the reading room. Eleven essays are up, more on the way, and a comments thread if you would like to leave a thought.

← Existentialism

King of Swords · Existentialism

King of Swords Tarot Card and Beauvoir: An Eye for an Eye

King of Swords

The archetype

The King sits facing us, sword in hand, as if about to hand down a verdict. An existentialist wants to know: what does the one passing judgment have to carry?

How does Existentialism read the King of Swords?

After the Second World War, France put collaborators with the Nazis on trial. In early 1945, Simone de Beauvoir attended the trial of the writer Robert Brasillach, who was sentenced to death for collaboration. Many writers signed a petition asking for clemency; Beauvoir didn’t sign. The next year she published an essay, “An Eye for an Eye,” facing squarely the unease the whole affair left in her.

She argues that punishment treats the criminal as a person responsible for his freedom, while the crime itself denied the victim’s standing as a human being. She offers no comfortable answer; she takes the whole weight of the judgment onto herself. Reading the King of Swords, an existentialist sees that kind of clarity: judge decisively, admit there’s a choice behind the judgment, and own the choice.

Reading the King of Swords upright

Upright, you’re willing to make hard calls and take responsibility for them, without hiding behind the rules.

Reading the King of Swords reversed

Reversed, you may be using “that’s just the policy” as a shield, unwilling to admit the choice was yours.

In love and connection

Whether to forgive someone has no textbook answer. Whatever you choose, own it as your choice.

In work and direction

When you make an unpopular decision, explain your reasons yourself instead of pinning it on your boss or the system.

A question to sit with

Have you lately used “I had no choice” to cover a choice you actually made?

A practice for this week

① Write down a hard decision you made recently. ② Write down why you chose it. ③ Change “I had to” to “I chose to,” and read it again.

A note on using this reading

This content is for self-reflection and entertainment only and does not constitute medical, legal, or financial advice.

Want a live reading for your own question? Draw with The Questioner of Freedom

Draw with Sage →

This page is generated from a 78×10 template matrix and editorially reviewed. It is not ten human authors writing separately. About · editorial standards