Blog field notes are now in print A long-form section has joined the reading room. Eleven essays are up, more on the way, and a comments thread if you would like to leave a thought.

← Confucianism

Eight of Cups · Confucianism

Eight of Cups Tarot Card and Confucius: Leaving Lu

Eight of Cups

The archetype

In the Eight of Cups, the figure in the red cloak has already turned around and is heading for the mountains, leaving the eight cups where they stand. A Confucian looking at this remembers that both Confucius and Mencius once walked out of a state.

How does Confucianism read the Eight of Cups?

The Analects (“Wei Zi,” 18.4) records it in a single line: the people of Qi sent a troupe of female musicians as a gift, Ji Huanzi accepted them, and for three days no court was held; Confucius left. Ji Huanzi was the man actually running the state of Lu. Confucius had held office there and had real hopes for it, but once the people in charge stopped caring about governing, staying had no point. He didn’t make a scene. He packed and went.

Mencius left the state of Qi much more slowly. In the Mencius (2B12), he spent three nights in the border town of Zhou before moving on, and someone mocked him for dragging his feet. Mencius replied, in substance: coming a thousand li to see the king was what I wanted; leaving because we didn’t meet minds was not what I wanted, I had no choice. Even spending three nights in Zhou felt too fast to me. He was hoping the king would change his mind and send for him. Reading the Eight of Cups, a Confucian sees two ways of leaving, one brisk and one reluctant. Both men went because their way couldn’t be practiced there, and both still cared about the place they left.

Reading the Eight of Cups upright

Upright, you see that there’s no longer room here for what you care about, and you leave calmly.

Reading the Eight of Cups reversed

Reversed, you may keep leaving and turning back, waiting too long for the other side to change.

In love and connection

You can leave someone without a fight. Leave them some dignity, and keep some for yourself.

In work and direction

If a team no longer cares about what you care about, hand over your work properly, then go.

A question to sit with

Who are you waiting on to change their mind, and how many more nights will you wait?

A practice for this week

① Write down a place you want to leave but haven’t. ② Write down the change you’re waiting for. ③ Give yourself a deadline, and decide when it arrives.

A note on using this reading

This content is for self-reflection and entertainment only and does not constitute medical, legal, or financial advice.

Want a live reading for your own question? Draw with The Cultivator of Character

Draw with Elder Ren →

This page is generated from a 78×10 template matrix and editorially reviewed. It is not ten human authors writing separately. About · editorial standards